 |
| "BETTER" than Going My Way?? |
Plot synopsis: A curmudgeonly small-town doctor (Barry Fitzgerald) decides to take a vacation (his "first in 30 years") and hires a replacement -- preferably a "mature" man, a "man of substance". His replacement turns out to be a singing doctor played by none other than Bing Crosby. At first they don't get along, and Bing has a tough time adjusting to the locals. But then, he eventually wins over everyone (the movie plays out much better than it sounds).
If that synopsis sounds familiar, then you may be familiar with Bing & Barry's first pairing,
Going My Way; screenwriter Frank Butler was a co-writer on both pictures.
In fact, Paramount's ad campaign went so far as to proclaim
Welcome Stranger even "Better!" than
Going My Way.
Wow. That's quite a praise. I did like
Going My Way so this has some big shoes to fill.
I could just imagine the word-of-mouth during the summer of 1947 -
Hey Barney, did you see that new picture with Bing Crosby and that little Irish fellow?
You mean that new one where they play doctors?
Yes, sir! That picture had me in stitches! I was laughing to beat the band!
Does Bing sing in it?
Yeah he sings about 3 or 4 new songs. One I can't get out of my head: "Smile Right Back at the Sun". Oh, and he does a fun square dance number.
Is it just as good as Going My Way?
Yeah...those posters were right...it's even better. This one leaves out all that religious stuff. And Joan Caufield is is it too.
Wow, she's one of my favorite picture stars. I can't wait to see it!
Here's how the marquee of the Oakland Theater in Oakland, California looked in 1947 when the film showed there. (Photo credit:
Theaters of Oakland, California by Jack Tillmany, Arcadia Publishing, 2006)
 |
| Welcome Stranger was released June 13, 1947 |
Welcome Stranger was the second of 3 movies to star Bing and Barry. Their first teaming was of course 1944's wartime success
Going My Way which earned Oscars for both actors and became the biggest hit movie of 1944 (and Best Picture Oscar winner). (Their 3rd and last movie together, 1949's
Top of the Morning, co-starring Ann Blyth, didn't do as well as the first two).
Welcome Stranger was sort of like the
Jurassic World of 1947. It's story and screenplay borrowed the same formula from the original hit, and brought back it's colossal star attractions (Bing & Barry were as big as dinosaurs at that time, especially Bing, who was the T-Rex of movie stars back then) in a surefire attempt to recapture the magic of that earlier picture.
And sure enough,
Welcome Stranger became a big hit at the box office. [1]

According to the book
Box Office Hits by Susan Sackett,
Welcome Stranger was the #1 box office success for 1947 in terms of rental figures.* The book features essays on each of the Top Five box office hits of 1947, and ranked them in this order:
1)
Welcome Stranger, Paramount ($6,100,000)
2)
The Egg and I, Universal ($5,500,000)
3)
Unconquered, Paramount ($5,250,000)
4)
Life With Father, Warner Bros ($5,057,000)
5)
Forever Amber, 20th Century Fox ($5,000,000)
*In the book, Sackett explains that rental figures represent the amount of money paid to the distributors of a film (IE studios) by those who rent a film (IE, the movie theaters).
After watching the movie, I can see why the movie was such a hit. It has the wonderful appeal and chemistry of Bing and Barry, plus some snappy new songs, and some really funny moments throughout the picture that - in my opinion - hold up pretty good after all these years (almost 70 years later!). Barry made me laugh with just his facial expressions alone! My favorite jokes in the movie are the ones about Bing's real-life Hollywood pals Bob Hope and Frank Sinatra - I won't give away the jokes but they cracked me up! True, those jokes may be dated to a younger audience--- but if you know about Bing, Bob, and Frank then you'll laugh! I also liked it whenever Barry calls Bing a "young man" (Bing was 43).
 |
| Yep, they were right |
So.... did I enjoy
Welcome Stranger more than
Going My Way? Hmmm. Well, that's not a easy one to answer! I only recently experienced
Welcome Stranger after many years of searching for a copy of it - and I loved it.
Going My Way, which I first saw years ago, is the sentimental favorite. But since it's fresh in my mind, I'll give
Welcome Stranger the edge! Hats off to that promotional team!
As long as you can suspend your disbelief that Bing Crosby is a surgeon, then I think you will enjoy this movie too, which is part musical, part comedy and part romance - yes Bing falls for Joan Caufield, but that's not really a spoiler (not only her, but
another lovely lady has a crush on him, Wanda Belix). The film also has some dramatic moments, but not too melodramatic; a scene involving an emergency appendectomy will leave you laughing more than wincing.
 |
| Bing teaches Barry to catch fish with a song |
About the film, Greenbriar Picture Shows wrote:
"Hayrides, square dances, and picket-fence values call up pleasant memory of Will Rogers and a middle America he presided over. Bing Crosby feels very much like Will's successor in Welcome, Stranger, dispensing pills and common sense with song" [2]
Finally, I discovered a very interesting WordPress blog by a real country doctor - A Country Doctor Writes - he has practiced small-town medicine for over 30 years, just like Barry Fitzgerald in the movie. In
his insightful post on
Welcome Stranger, the doctor writes -
"a wonderfully relevant commentary on medicine in 1947, and also today....the tension between practical wisdom and academic theory in medicine exists today as much as it did in 1947...it portrays a bygone era, and at the same time it makes us think about where we are today." [3]
I also highly recommend this film, and give it an "A".
A must see for Bing Crosby fans, fans of whimsical comedy-romance-musicals of the 1940s, and anyone curious to see how Bing and Barry follow up
Going My Way.
Trivia and Miscellaneous
Available on VHS cassette tape (hard to find) and DVD in the Bing Crosby 6 movie collection. (Thank you to YouTuber
Nicoley133 for providing information about the DVDs)
Directed by Elliott Nugent (
The Cat and the Canary, Give Me a Sailor, The Male Animal, My Favorite Brunette). Cinematography by Lionel Lindon (Oscar winner for
Around the World in 80 Days).
Co-starring Robert Shayne, Thurston Hall, and Percy Kilbride ("Pa Kettle" from
The Egg and I) . Pioneering black actors Clarence Muse and Clarence Brooks have small uncredited roles in the early train sequence .[4,5] Frank Faylen ("Ernie" from
It's a Wonderful Life) has a small role as a sick reporter; his character pays off in the end when he delivers Bing some important news.
Despite the ad proclamations about this film being "Better" than
Going My Way, Welcome Stranger did not receive any Academy Award nominations - not even any for Best Song.
No one in the film actually says "Welcome, Stranger!" In my research of this film I discovered that "Welcome Stranger" was the title of a very popular (at the time) 1920 Broadway Play (written by Aaron Hoffman and produced by Sam Harris) about a narrow-minded New England town that overcomes their prejudice and accepts a newcomer. [5] That's about
the only thing the play and 1947 Bing movie have in common (in the play, the newcomer is a Jew). A silent film based on the play opened in 1924. [6] The play's title (also inspired by a sacred scripture teaching to "welcome the stranger") grew to become something of a catchphrase and was borrowed for this 1947 Bing-Barry picture.
References
1.
The Hollywood Reporter Book of Box Office Hits by Susan Sackett (Watson-Guptill Publications, May 1996, pages 66-71)
2. Greenbriar Picture Shows (blog).
Another Bing Crosby Collection (published December 16, 2010)
3. A Country Doctor Writes (blog).
Welcome Stranger (published January 11, 2011)
4. Black Cinema Connection (blog).
Clarence Brooks (published September 29, 2014)
5. African American Registry (website).
Clarence Muse: A Pioneer Film Actor (accessed July 12, 2015)
6.
The Jewish Forum: A Monthly Magazine, Volume 3. (Jewish Forum Publishing Company, January 1, 1920, page 630)
7. Lake Worth Playhouse (website).
Lake Worth Playhouse History (accessed July 1, 2015)
Additional photos
Here are some photos showing the chapter on 1947 from the book
Box Office Hits by Susan Sackett, with
Welcome Stranger getting an impressive 2-page spread: