I went to see this movie knowing nothing about the story - I had not read the book nor knew anything about what happens.
But I liked it. It definitely kept me in suspense, and left me trying to put together all the pieces in my head throughout the movie. I liked the performance by David Strathairn who plays the lawyer. He's good, but I don't think this is an Academy-Award nominated role (even though I think he definitely deserves an Oscar).
I liked the main lead, and thought she looked alot like Anne Hathaway to me, so much so that I wondered why the real Anne Hathaway couldn't have been cast (is she too old - gasp!). The marsh where she lives was depicted as so serene and secluded and safe...until the threat comes - a crazy ex.
The only likeable people in the town is the Black couple who own the local variety store in town. I liked those characters, and wished their characters had more screen time and were somehow more involved.
I liked the scene when the brother comes back. And I liked how they showed all her drawings and illustrations, and I wished the movie focused on them some more.
Trivia - the actor who played "Angus" in the 1990s movie Angus has a small cameo in a bar at the beginning. Not sure how he got involved, but I also wish his part was way longer. Can we say "comeback"?
Sigh! Maybe another director would have had more vision.
But otherwise I recommend the movie. Even if it feels like something that might be made-for-tv.